City

Shelter Island, NY

1 ZIP code  ·  Suffolk County  ·  New York

👥2,858Population
💰$129,826Median HH Income▲ 70% above avg
🎂42.4Median Age
🏠$998,700Median Home Value▲ 258% above avg
🎓62.0%College Grads▲ 60% above avg
📊3.9%Unemployment▼ 19% below avg
People & Population (ACS 2023 — weighted avg)
♂ Male 47.7% Female 52.3% ♀

Race & Ethnicity

White: 62.1%Hispanic: 21.1%Black: 0.9%Asian: 6.1%Race
White62.1%
Hispanic21.1%
Black0.9%
Asian6.1%

Age Breakdown

Under 5
12%
5–17
11%
18–24
8%
25–44
26%
45–64
15%
65+
14%

Key Indicators

Median Age42.4 yrs
Avg HH Size2.58
Below Poverty3.7% ▼ 63% below avg
College Grads62.0% ▲ 60% above avg
Unemployment3.9% ▼ 19% below avg
HS Graduate392 (21.9%)
Some College43 (2.4%)
Associates244 (13.7%)
Bachelors81 (4.5%)
Graduate Degree1,027 (57.5%)

Education

HS Grad: 21.9%Some College: 2.4%Associates: 13.7%Bachelors: 4.5%Graduate: 57.5%Edu
HS Grad21.9%
Some College2.4%
Associates13.7%
Bachelors4.5%
Graduate57.5%
Housing & Income

Housing Tenure

Owner: 93.9%Renter: 6.1%Tenure
Owner93.9%
Renter6.1%

Home Value Distribution

$50k–$100k
3%
$150k–$200k
5%
$200k–$300k
5%
$300k–$500k
7%
Over $500k
79%

Financials

Median HH Income$129,826 ▲ 70% above avg
Median Home Value$998,700 ▲ 258% above avg
Home/Income Ratio7.7x (nat avg ~3.5x)
Total Housing Units2,483
Vacant Units1,387

Income Distribution

Under $25k
10%
$25k–$50k
7%
$50k–$75k
14%
$75k–$100k
3%
$100k–$150k
18%
$150k–$200k
14%
Over $200k
35%
Employment & Commute

How People Get to Work

Drove Alone
51%
Public Transit
14%
Walked
0%
Work From Home
35%

Commute Time

Under 15 min
54%
15–30 min
10%
30–45 min
16%
Over 45 min
19%
Housing Stock

Year Built

1940s–1950s
22%
1960s–1970s
7%
1980s–1990s
15%
2000+
57%
About Shelter Island, NY

Shelter Island is a city in New York, located in Suffolk County. The city spans 1 ZIP code and is home to approximately 2,858 residents. It is a middle-aged city, with a median age of 42.4 years.

Economically, Shelter Island is a upper-middle-income community. The median household income of $129,826 is significantly above the national average. Approximately 3.7% of residents live below the poverty line. The unemployment rate is 3.9%, below the national average.

The real estate market in Shelter Island is among the most expensive housing markets in the country. Median home values stand at $998,700, which is more than double the national average. Homeownership is high at 93.9%, typical of suburban and family-oriented communities.

The population of Shelter Island is highly educated. 62.0% of adults hold a bachelor's degree or higher — significantly above the national average. The community is majority White (62.14%).

Shelter Island, NY offers residents above-average earning potential within New York.

ZIP Codes in Shelter Island
ZIPPopulationMedian IncomeMedian HomeMedian RentUnemp.CollegeOwner Occ.
11964 2,858 $129,826 $998,700 3.9% 62.0% 93.9%